Thursday, November 8, 2012
Fund's return vs Shareholder's return in ICAP
But the same can't be said to your return as a shareholder during these period. The market price on 22nd June 2012 is only RM 2.15, giving you a return of negative 22.7%.
Why is NAV grows 32.4% during these period, while your return as a shareholder is -22.7% ?
It's because at the time of purchase, you're paying 25.2% PREMIUM over NAV, and at the time of sale, people is paying you 26.9% DISCOUNT over NAV.
While buying at discount to NAV is good, it is at the expense of the seller. So is vice versa to buying at premium.
Thus, the best way to be fair to both buyer and seller for the fund to trade close to its NAV, and the best way to achieve this is to have a policy by ICAP to ensure that the gap between NAV and market price isn't wide (say, anything more than plus or minus 5%).
Data available here: http://www.icapital.my/en/weeklynav
And the reason i vote for Laxey is because i'm voting for the gap between market price and NAV to reduce to be fair to both the buyer and seller. Although i know most of you are long term investors, but should you decide to sell one day, you would want to sell at a fair price, don't you?
Just like in Politics. Many vote for PKR not because they want Anwar. But it's because they want "change".
TTB, hope you'll close the gap by setting policy in place.
Wednesday, November 7, 2012
Warren Buffett's wisdom to guide ICAP shareholders to vote properly.
"The companies in which we have our largest investments have all engaged in significant stock repurhases at times when wide discrepancies existed between price and value. As shareholders, we find this encouraging and rewarding for two important reasons - one that is obvious, and one that is subtle and not always understood. The obvious point involves basic arithmetic: major repurchases at prices well below per-share intrinsic business value immediately increase, in a highly significant way, that value. When companies purchase their own stock, they often find it easy to get $2 of present value for $1. Corporate acquisition programs almost never do as well and, in a discouragingly large number of cases, fail to get anything close to $1 of value for each $1 expended.
The other benefit of repurchases is less subject to precise measurement but can be fully as important over time. By making repurchases when a company’s market value is well below its business value, management clearly demonstrates that it is given to actions that enhance the wealth of shareholders, rather than to actions that expand management’s domain but that do nothing for (or even harm) shareholders. Seeing this, shareholders and potential shareholders increase their estimates of future returns from the business. This upward revision, in turn, produces market prices more in line with intrinsic business value. These prices are entirely rational. Investors should pay more for a
business that is lodged in the hands of a manager with demonstrated pro-shareholder leanings than for one in the hands of a self-interested manager marching to a different drummer. (To make the point extreme, how much would you pay to be a minority shareholder of a company controlled by Robert Wesco?)
The key word is “demonstrated”. A manager who consistently turns his back on repurchases, when these clearly are in the interests of owners, reveals more than he knows of his motivations. No matter how often or how eloquently he mouths some public relations-inspired phrase such as “maximizing
shareholder wealth” (this season’s favorite), the market correctly discounts assets lodged with him. His heart is not listening to his mouth - and, after a while, neither will the market."
Surprisingly, this 3 paragraphs was written by Buffett in 1984 letters to his Berkshire Shareholders. [ Source: http://berkshirehathaway.com/letters/1984.html ]
Mr. Tan Teng Boo, if you're reading this, i'm sure Warren Buffett don't mean you since he wouldn't know what's going to happen 28 years after writing that article. But don't you agree his words of advice is timeless?
Tuesday, November 6, 2012
Letter to shareholders of Icapital.biz Bhd. from Laxey Partners Ltd, the largest single shareholder in the company
As of 2nd November 2012, funds managed by Laxey Partners Ltd ("Laxey") owned 9,645,191 shares in Icapital.biz Bhd ("ICAP"), being 6.89% of the shares in issue. Laxey have been a Shareholder since 2010 in ICAP.
The purpose of this letter is to provide Shareholders with information relating to the Resolutions to be tabled at the forthcoming AGM. We would urge you to:
Vote Against Resolution 3: To re‐elect Datuk Ng Peng Hong @ Ng Peng Hay
Vote Against Resolution 4: To re‐elect Dato’ Dr. Norraesah Binti Mohamad
Vote Against Resolution 6: To re‐appoint Tunku Tan Sri Dato Seri Ahmad
Vote Against Resolution 7: To re‐appoint Tunku Abdul Aziz bin Tunku Ibrahim
Vote FOR Resolution 10: To elect Mr. Andrew Pegge as Director
Vote FOR Resolution 11: To elect Mr. Lo Kok Kee as Director
Vote FOR Resolution 12: To elect Mr. Low Nyap Heng as Director
Vote Against Resolution 13: To elect to elect Dato’ Tan Ang Meng as Director
Vote Against Resolution 14: To elect Dr. Yin Thing Phee @ Yin Thing Phi as Director
The Rationale:
Massive Persistent Discount:
While the manager has done a good job by delivering a NAV growth which has outperformed the FTSE Bursa Malaysia KLCI Index since inception, we are concerned about the substantial discount to Net Asset Value (“NAV”) that the fund has traded at and indeed continues to trade at. For the record we attach two charts from the Company 2012 Annual Report:
Independence of the Board & Corporate Governance Issues:
The Chairman, Tunku Tan Sri Dato Sri Ahmad bin Tunku Yahya, is non‐independent because of his indirect shareholding in Capital Dynamics Asset Management S/B, the Fund Manager of the Company. From 1982 to 1993, he was Group CEO of the Sime Darby Bhd Group and until 2007, was its Deputy Chairman. An Independent Director, Mr. David Loo Kean Beng, started his career with Sime Darby Berhad in 1987 and left in 1997 as Senior Legal Adviser. Another INED, Tunku Abdul Aziz bin Tunku Ibrahim, was at one time, group director of Sime Darby Ltd, the exact period for which has not been specified.The present composition of Directors would meet the requirements of the Bursa listing rules, but in terms of corporate governance, is it ideal? Should our Board be filled by a group of Directors with past ties to each other?
On 1st November, the Company announced the 5 additional nominees for election as Directors of the
Company at the forthcoming AGM.
Moving Forward:
We believe that a Board of Directors should bring forward proposals to eliminate or substantially narrow the discount that the shares of the Company trade at relative to their NAV. This is a growing problem for our Company.The Company could, as a minimum, consider implementing a share buy‐back scheme in accordance with the provisions of Section 67A of the Companies Act, 1965 of Malaysia, in order to give investors confidence and to boost the demand for the shares of the Company. We believe that the Board should concurrently engage advisors to research other methods to permanently remove the substantial discount at which the shares trade.
We have lost our confidence in the ability and commitment of the Board to address such an important issue.
Conclusion:
Profile of Andrew Pegge:
Andrew Pegge, a British citizen, is 100% independent of the ICAP.Andrew Pegge started his investment career with Laurentian Fund Management in 1987. In 1990 he joined Buchanan Partners Limited where he was initially responsible for systems planning and integration, later developing a process of systematic analysis and management of investment situations in both mainstream and emerging equity markets. In 1995, Andrew, with Colin Kingsnorth, set up Kingpin, where as Chairman he had responsibility for managing the group's global emerging markets; Following the decision to relocate to the Isle of Man, Andrew spent six months with the Isle of Man Financial Supervision Commission as Supervisor of Collective Investment Schemes. After 8 months in this role he left, in late 1999 to found Laxey Partners Limited again with Mr Kingsnorth. He holds an Honours degree in Psychology and Cognitive Studies, an MBA and is a CFA charter holder.
Mr Pegge currently sit on the boards of a number of public listed companies as Independent Non‐ executive director, including ASA Limited – a Bermudan domiciled New York Stock Exchange listed fund that comes under the supervision of the United States SEC; Sefalana Holding Company a company both domiciled and listed in Botswana; and the Value Catalyst Fund Limited – a fund managed by Laxey Partners that recently delisted having offered shareholders the opportunity of electing for realisation shares at NAV. He contributes significantly in his roles as Member of various board committees.
Profile of Low Nyap Heng:
Mr. Low Nyap Heng is a Malaysian, aged 61 and a Fellow member of the Institute of Chartered Secretaries and Administrators, United Kingdom. He was the Chief Executive Officer of Ayer Hitam Tin Dredging (Malaysia) Berhad from 1991 to 1993. He had also served as Executive Director of Kampung Lanjut Tin Dredging Berhad and Director of Roxy Industries Malaysia Berhad and Projects for Asia Management Sdn Bhd. He was also the Executive Director of Jackin International Holdings Limited from 2003 to 2007, the shares of which are listed on the main board of The Stock Exchange of Hong Kong Limited. Currently he is the Vice President of Cen‐1 Partners, a corporate advisory and consultancy firm in Hong Kong.Profile of Lo Kok Kee:
Mr. Lo was director and shareholder of Jupiter Securities Sdn Bhd, participating organization of Bursa Malaysia Securities Bhd. Prior to that, he was director and shareholder of OSK & Partners Sdn Bhd, the forerunner of the present OSK Investment Bank.Mr. Lo has long been involved in shareholder activism, before it became fashionable. In 1990, he unsuccessfully proposed the open‐ending of Overseas Union Securities Ltd.(OUS), a closed‐end fund listed on the Singapore Stock Exchange, which was trading at persistent deep discount to net asset. OUS has since merged with United International Securities Ltd. while the other two closed‐end funds, Harimau Investments Ltd and General Securities Investment Ltd, had gone into members’ voluntary liquidation, after failing to narrow the persistent discount to NAV.
More recently, in 2009, he initiated and successfully moved the members’ voluntary liquidation of Amanah Harta Tanah PNB2 (AHP2), an underperforming real estate investment trust managed by PNB, the first such liquidation in the history of the Bursa. Members were able to realise a distribution of RM 1 compared to the prior market price of around 50 sen/unit.
Mr. Lo holds bachelor degrees in Agriculture and Economics from the University of Saskatchewan, Canada as a Colombo Plan scholar. He also holds an MBA, majoring in Finance and Accounting, from the Chicago Booth Business School, University of Chicago, where he studied under Nobel laureates Professors Merton Miller and Myron Scholes.
Thursday, March 29, 2012
Value Investing = Get Rich Quick ?
The email (written by the organiser) is as follows:
"If you like to get rich quickly, this is the way. Please kindly circulate this to all your friends who are also interested to get rich quickly."
Well, I did forward and highly recommend that seminar to a few of my friends, but NOT because I or they want to get rich quickly. I forward and personally will be attending the seminar because I think the philosophies and investment styles of Benjamin Graham, Philip Fisher and Warren Buffett is very good (if not excellent).
Anyway, here's what Warren Buffett said about Sound / Value Investing.
“Ben Graham wasn’t about brilliant investments and he wasn’t about fads of fashion. He was about sound investing, and I think sound investing can make you very wealthy if you’re not in too big of a hurry. And it never makes you poor, which is even better.”
[Source: http://www.trinitywealth.ca/articles/500MostWittyThings.pdf ]
And lastly, i end with a quote i read somewhere that says,
"The only thing fast about money, .... is losing it!"
Friday, December 23, 2011
Sunday, September 25, 2011
We try to price, rather than time, purchases.
____________________________________________________________________
We try to price, rather than time, purchases. In our view, it is folly to forego buying shares in an outstanding business whose long-term future is predictable, because of short-term worries about an economy or a stock market that we know to be unpredictable. Why scrap an informed decision because of an uninformed guess?
We purchased National Indemnity in 1967, See's in 1972, Buffalo News in 1977, Nebraska Furniture Mart in 1983, and Scott Fetzer in 1986 because those are the years they became available and because we thought the prices they carried were acceptable. In each case, we pondered what the business was likely to do, not what the Dow, the Fed, or the economy might do. If we see this approach as making sense in the purchase of businesses in their entirety, why should we change tack when we are purchasing small pieces of wonderful businesses in the stock market?
Before looking at new investments, we consider adding to old ones. If a business is attractive enough to buy once, it may well pay to repeat the process. We would love to increase our economic interest in See's or Scott Fetzer, but we haven't found a way to add to a 100% holding. In the stock market, however, an investor frequently gets the chance to increase his economic interest in businesses he knows and likes.
Wednesday, August 10, 2011
Friday, November 12, 2010
Worth over a hundred millions, and get paid in tens of millions a year

How are they paid so high? There's a quote that says, "The best way to get what you want, is to deserve it."
Do they deserve to get paid so high?
Value Partners manage Value Partners Classic Fund, which have gained 2,173.0% from 1st April 1993 up to 29th October 2010, an annualized return of 19.4% over 17+ years! They manage USD 4.5 Billion and USD 7.3 Billion for the year ending 2006 and 2007 while earning 41.8% and 41.1% for their Classic Fund investors (A Units) for the year 2006 and 2007.
Since they add value to their fund investors, i believe they deserve such high pay (they're paid 1.25% management fee + 15% performance fee).

At the end of 2007, the each share is priced at HK$ 7.63 (about RM 3.3572), while as of this posting (12th Nov 2010), the share is priced at HK$ 7.27 (about RM 2.908). So, they're worth above RM 100 Million each (except for Mr. Law, who joins the company only in the December 2004).
Cheah Cheng Hye is a Billionaire in HK$ as well as in RM. And he's a Malaysian (Penangite, and an old frees, not to mention he's also one of the top chess player in Penang Free School back then.)
Source of the information: 2007 Annual Report of Value Partners Group
Value Partners Group's Website
Value Partners Classic Fund
Value Partners Investment Philosophies
Thursday, October 21, 2010
About Gold
Is Gold a good investment?
It depends what's your definition of "good". When compared to cash, i think Gold is a better choice, since government have the legal license to keep printing money and thus diluting our cash while we're not compensated enough from interest earned from our cash. That is assuming you're not buying Gold at an overvalued price.
But i don't keep my surplus in "cash". I don't enjoy being "poor" slowly but surely.
To me, keeping Gold is like running on a treadmill. Yes, you're running, but you're going nowhere (after adjusted for inflation). On the other hand, keeping cash is even worse! That's like walking up slower than the escalator coming down, and thereby you're moving slower and slower down.
Question : Where do you think gold will be in five years and should that be a part of value investing?
Buffett : I have no views as to where it will be, but the one thing I can tell you is it won't do anything between now and then except look at you. Whereas, you know, Coca-Cola will be making money, and I think Wells Fargo will be making a lot of money and there will be a lot--and it's a lot--it's a lot better to have a goose that keeps laying eggs than a goose that just sits there and eats insurance and storage and a few things like that. The idea of digging something up out of the ground, you know, in South Africa or someplace and then transporting it to the United States and putting into the ground, you know, in the Federal Reserve of New York, does not strike me as a terrific asset.
Source: Ask Warren Buffett on CNBC's Squawk Box - Part 7 (9th March 2009)
Buffett also says "You could take all the gold that's ever been mined, and it would fill a cube 67 feet in each direction. For what that's worth at current gold prices, you could buy all -- not some -- all of the farmland in the United States. Plus, you could buy 10 Exxon Mobils, plus have $1 trillion of walking-around money. Or you could have a big cube of metal. Which would you take? Which is going to produce more value?"
Benjamin Graham in The Intelligent Investor also expresses his opposition to investing in gold.
Jeremy Siegel in Stocks for the Long Run writes how gold has barely beaten inflation over the past 200 years.
It is impossible to put an intrinsic value on gold. Companies or properties can be evaluated in numerous ways based on earnings, assets, growth etc. However, gold is just a metal which has no intrinsic value. Any time you are buying without establishing a margin of safety you are more likely speculating than you are investing.
If you buy gold at $1350 an ounce and it drops 50% there is no way to tell if it is trading above, at, or below its intrinsic value. That is why you will have no idea what do to if there is a sharp decline in gold prices. On the other hand, if you buy a property or stocks of a good company, you can check to see whether the earnings is affected as much as the drop in the price.
Take for instance, if you buy a property at RM 200,000 that gives you a Net annual rental of RM 20,000, giving you an annual rental return of 10%. If after 3 months and the property price drops to RM 100,000, we can check to see if the rental drops or not. If the rental did not drop, then we'll know that the property's intrinsic value did not drop. In fact, we can confidently buy more provided that the property price drop while rental remains. I don't know how we can say the same thing with Gold.
Owning a goose that lays eggs vs a goose that does nothing
From the green line of the graph above, it shows that Dow grows at a higher rate than Gold. Owning Equities represents ownership of companies and owning good companies is like owning a Goose that keeps on laying eggs.Does Gold price keeps going up?
No! Infact, if you have bought at the "peak" in 1980, you have to wait 27 years to breakeven, and that's not including the depreciation of money over these 27 years. At this high price of gold currently, it's quite hard to justify recommending investing in gold.
Saturday, September 18, 2010
Letter to a fund manager of a local Insurance Company
In the year ending Nov 30th, 2007, A** Equity Fund had 92.6% in Equities. That time, the index was 1,396.98. 1 year later, when KLCI is at 866.14, A**'s Equity Fund's equity exposure drop to 42.5% ! Isn't that "buy high, sell low"?

Date ------------------- KLCI ---------------A** Equity Fund's Equity Exposure
30th Nov 2007 --------1,396.98 ---------------------------92.6%
30th Nov 2008 ---------866.14 ----------------------------42.5% !!!
Shouldn't it be the other way round? And if the fund manager can't time the market (which i believe nobody can), shouldn't A** Equity Fund maintains as an "Equity" Fund with 70% to 90% in Equity? Having 42.5% in Equity is less than what a balanced fund is putting! And having 42.5% in Equity when prices are low is even more unexplainable!
Please explain this when i can't see any logical reasons for it (other than the fund manager having "buy high, sell low" syndrome, or join the herd mentality to be fearful when prices are low or trying to gamble the market's direction).
And in year 2009, KLCI earned 44.7% while A** equity fund earned less than 2/5 of KLCI's return! And the annual report don't even mention the reason for such poor performance! If the unit holders are truly the owners of that fund, don't they deserve an explaination for such poor performance?
And please don't say that A**'s equity fund return of 17.5% is better than FD! If you travel from Penang to Singapore by flight, and reach there after 7 hours (when other air planes can reach within 1 hour), do you accept excuse as "At least our flight is faster than going by car" ?
As a result, A** under perform KLCI during these times. Am i right to say that? If that is so, then what's the point of hiring A** as the fund manager for their equity funds? Might as well they just buy the Index or ETF and save the 1.5% management fees, and don't earn a return WORSE than KLCI (not to mention savings on the huge upfront service charge, or ended up being tied up to the terrible fund for 6 years to enjoy 0% service charge).
And also, please don't say A** equity fund beat benchmark since launch. The comparison is simply not fair because KLCI doesn't include dividends into their price. Had KLCI add between 3% to 4.5% yearly dividends to the price, A** Equity fund would under perform by a wide margin!
Waiting for an explaination for me to explain to my unhappy clients.
Monday, August 16, 2010
Walter Schloss by Warren Buffett
____________________________________________________________________
Let me end this section by telling you about one of the good guys of Wall Street, my long-time
friend Walter Schloss, who last year turned 90. From 1956 to 2002, Walter managed a remarkably
successful investment partnership, from which he took not a dime unless his investors made money. My admiration for Walter, it should be noted, is not based on hindsight. A full fifty years ago, Walter was my sole recommendation to a St. Louis family who wanted an honest and able investment manager.
Walter did not go to business school, or for that matter, college. His office contained one file
cabinet in 1956; the number mushroomed to four by 2002. Walter worked without a secretary, clerk or bookkeeper, his only associate being his son, Edwin, a graduate of the North Carolina School of the Arts. Walter and Edwin never came within a mile of inside information. Indeed, they used “outside” information only sparingly, generally selecting securities by certain simple statistical methods Walter learned while working for Ben Graham. When Walter and Edwin were asked in 1989 by Outstanding Investors Digest, “How would you summarize your approach?” Edwin replied, “We try to buy stocks cheap.” So much for Modern Portfolio Theory, technical analysis, macroeconomic thoughts and complex algorithms.
Following a strategy that involved no real risk – defined as permanent loss of capital – Walter
produced results over his 47 partnership years that dramatically surpassed those of the S&P 500. It’s particularly noteworthy that he built this record by investing in about 1,000 securities, mostly of a lackluster type. A few big winners did not account for his success. It’s safe to say that had millions of investment managers made trades by a) drawing stock names from a hat; b) purchasing these stocks in comparable amounts when Walter made a purchase; and then c) selling when Walter sold his pick, the luckiest of them would not have come close to equaling his record. There is simply no possibility that what Walter achieved over 47 years was due to chance.
I first publicly discussed Walter’s remarkable record in 1984. At that time “efficient market
theory” (EMT) was the centerpiece of investment instruction at most major business schools. This theory, as then most commonly taught, held that the price of any stock at any moment is not demonstrably mispriced, which means that no investor can be expected to overperform the stock market averages using only publicly-available information (though some will do so by luck). When I talked about Walter 23 years ago, his record forcefully contradicted this dogma.
And what did members of the academic community do when they were exposed to this new and
important evidence? Unfortunately, they reacted in all-too-human fashion: Rather than opening their minds, they closed their eyes. To my knowledge no business school teaching EMT made any attempt to study Walter’s performance and what it meant for the school’s cherished theory.
Instead, the faculties of the schools went merrily on their way presenting EMT as having the
certainty of scripture. Typically, a finance instructor who had the nerve to question EMT had about as much chance of major promotion as Galileo had of being named Pope.
Tens of thousands of students were therefore sent out into life believing that on every day the price
of every stock was “right” (or, more accurately, not demonstrably wrong) and that attempts to evaluate businesses – that is, stocks – were useless. Walter meanwhile went on overperforming, his job made easier by the misguided instructions that had been given to those young minds. After all, if you are in the shipping business, it’s helpful to have all of your potential competitors be taught that the earth is flat.
Maybe it was a good thing for his investors that Walter didn’t go to college.
____________________________________________________________________
His record: http://peterlim80.blogspot.com/2008/10/superinvestors-of-graham-and-doddsville_21.html
A good writeup on Walter J Schloss : http://www.gurufocus.com/news_print.php?id=21786
Monday, May 31, 2010
How to know whether you're adequately insured ?
The truth is, you don't need life insurance. However, your dependence might need it! So, purchasing life insurance (especially when it's bought for the right reason) for your dependence, be it your parents, spouse or children(s), is a very generous and thougtful act.
In this post, i'll focus on the insurance Needs rather than What type of Policy, which i've posted about it here.
First, do you have any loans that you're responsible for? For example, if you're single and have housing loans, car loans, and credit card loans, you might not need to have any insurance to cover it, since you don't have any dependant. However, if you have spouse or children or parents who depends on the house or car, then you might want to insure that loan amount.
- How much is the outstanding loan balance that you're liable for currently?
Next is the current needs of you dependants. Is there anybody rely on you for their financial needs? If yes, then ask yourself these questions below for each group of dependants.
- How much do they need from you every year (excluding loan installments, since it's covered in a lump sum above) ?
A good start is the amount you give them currently. - How many years do they need from you?
If your dependant is your parents or your spouse, a good guide is to provide them for their entire life (age 85 and above). - What is their investment rate of return, conservatively estimated?
Note that it's "their" investment return, not "yours", since insurance company paid a lump sum (generally), and they will invest the money when you're no longer around. If they currently put most of their money in FD, then use the current FD rate.
Besides providing for current needs (as above), our dependant might have a future need too. For example, our children(s) might need a lump sum for their tertiary education. If you have any future needs, then do answer the below questions for each "future needs".
- What is the purpose of the future needs ?
Examples are like Education fund, Purchase/ upgrade home, World tour for your loved ones. For education fund, seperate each child's education fund. - When do your dependant needs it?
For education fund, they would need it usually at age 18. - When you're no longer around, what would your next-of-kin's investment return?
Warren Buffett's return might be high, but when he calculates his life insurance needs, he can't use his compounded return, since i doubt his wife would be able to earn his high rate of return from investments.
With these information, your total needs can then be calculated.
Then, calculate how much is your Net Worth (excluding your home, and your car).
The difference between your total needs and your Net Worth is your shortfall, which should be covered by insurance.
If your insurance is not enough, read this post to buy the right kind of policy. I'm personally insured for RM 1 Million, payable upon Life or 36 Critical Illnesses and paying a premium of not more than RM 200 monthly, at my current age of 29.
Wednesday, May 5, 2010
Company that offers ways to reduce your housing loan interest?
'Once upon a time, a Young Engineer with an income of $3,000 per month noticed he had extra time (after work). Thus, he decided to use the extra time to work in Mcdonalds as a cashier, earning RM 5.00 per hour. In a month, his part-time salary was around RM 500, since he worked 4 hours a day for 6 days a week.
Then one day, he went to his Mcdonalds boss to get higher pay. The conversation was as below:
Young Engineer: Boss, how can I earn more money from this job?
Boss: Simple, just work full time here, you'll double your pay! If that's not enough, u can work full-time and over-time! All in all, you'll triple your pay! (by tripling your working hours).
Young Engineer: But if I work full-time in Mcdonalds, don't I lose my income as an Engineer (which pays higher)?
Boss: We don't count your pay elsewhere. We ONLY count your pay from Mcdonalds!
Young Engineer: Thanks! If I were to take up your recommendation (to quit a higher paying job to earn in a lower paying job), how much should I pay you for "consultation" fees?
Boss: It's only 1.5% of your total pay you'll get over 30 years plus RM 1,500. (And boss show some confusing softwares calculating how much you'll earn by working in Mcdonalds over 30 years, to confuse you that it's really worth it to pay the boss 1.5% + RM 1,500 and quit his engineering job!).
Young Engineer: Wow, that's really worth it!'
There's a few lessons you can learn from this (which I'll link to so called "Mortgage Reduction Company")
- There's opportunity cost for your time or your money.
For every hour you spent earning money on one job, you've lost the opportunity to earn money on another job with that time you spent. The same applies to your money! For every dollar you spent on reducing your loan (and thereby reducing your interest charged), your money have lost the opportunity to increase your assets (and thereby lost the opportunity to earn return on those assets). - Earning more by working more isn't smart!
Smart people earns more by working more productively (spending same time, earning higher pay per hour). Likewise, when you allocate your money, what's important is NOT how much money you get (or save). What's important is how much you get (or save) in relation to how much capital you put in! - Your resources (be it time or money) are limited.
If you can earn RM 100 per hour doing a job you like, it's ok to hire person to do something you don't like for RM 10 per hour! Stop thinking about the "loss" of RM 10, but instead, compare it with the savings of your limited resources. With loan, instead of "worrying" about Debts and interest charges, compare it against the investment return that you can conservatively get elsewhere. Not all Debts/ Loans/ Liabilities are bad (then again, not all "Assets" are good). The key is not to be afraid of Debts, but to understand it, and at times, you can make use it to help you achieve an earlier financial freedom.
Now, let me get back to the main topic. Let me share with you some statements from a Mortgage Reduction website that seems to "mislead" people, and mislead them to focus on the wrong stuff.
- "Since this sounds like a gift from the heaven to me, I then made up my mind that one day, I could also help others to become debt free."
Notice he uses "debt free", and not "financially free". Do you need to be debt free to be financially free? CRAP! A beggar is debt free, but is he financially free? Donald Trump might have debts more than what most people can earn in their lifetime, but he is financially free! So, STOP equating debt free with financially free!. Both are different, and a person who can't differentiate the two often find themselves stuck in rat race. - "If you have a $100,000 Mortgage amortized for 30 Years with an Interest Rate of 10.50%, Monthly Compounding and the Monthly Payments are $914.74."
As of this writing, housing loans in Malaysia charges less than 4%, while that website quote 10.5%. Isn't that trying to "inflate the interest charged" so that it looks more than what it's suppose to be? - "Do you know that only $39.74 (4.24%) of the $914.74 payment is used to pay the balance? This means that a whopping of $875.00 (95.66%) of that FIRST payment goes toward interest."
While that statement based on the interest of 10.5% interest is true, BUT that statement mislead people to focus that interest payment in relation to monthly installment. Interest charged depends on the interest rate, NOT on monthly installment!
How does the $875.00 interest come about? Easy!
- Your outstanding balance at the beginning of the Month is $100,000.
- Multiply that by the interest rate (10.5%), and you'll get $10,500. This is the interest charged in a year (if your outstanding balance is $100,000 throughout the year).
- Then, divide the interest charged ($10,500) by 12, and you'll get $875.00!
Notice the calculation of interest? It doesn't care what your monthly installment is! And, whatever in excess of the interest ($875), the balance goes to reducing the principal.
So, your outstanding balance reduces the following month, and thus, the interest charged reduces too (in $, but not in % of outstanding balance)!
What happens if your monthly installment is $ 5,000 per month? The interest charged on the 1st month would still be the same, which is $875 (and more than 80% of your installment goes to principal reduction!). Notice it?
If not: Here's the answer. Stop relating interest charged to monthly installment!! Instead, relate interest charged to outstanding balance (in fact, this has already been calculated for us, which is the rate told by the bank, (duh...))
And at current housing loan rate at less than 4%, the interest charged is less than half what is shown on that so called "mortgage reduction website"!
___________________________________________________________________
So, the question is NOT to "save" or "reduce" your housing loan, but rather to Optimize it! No point saving/ reducing your housing loan if your investment return earns better than housing loan. If you still don't understand, read the story of the Young Engineer above again.
The only way to save interest is getting lower rate from the bank! Like the Young Engineer above, the only way (that makes sense) for him to get higher pay is to increase his pay per hour, not working more hours (and lose the time to do something else!).
Personally, I'm happy to borrow maximum loan, maximum tenure, since at current housing loan rate (BLR-2.25%) , I believe my investments can conservatively earn at least twice that rate over the loan tenure (which is 40 years).
Instead of prepaying more of my housing loan to save less than 4% interest yearly, I rather invest the excess to earn at least 8% yearly, conservatively estimated. And that surplus will earn more surpluses over time, and compound the effect over time.
But if you don't know how to earn a return higher than your housing loan, then there's nothing wrong to use the surplus to reduce housing loan. Either way, comparison between housing loan's interest rate vs. your investment returns, conservatively estimated, and NOT blindly pay just to save housing loan interest!
Tuesday, May 4, 2010
Sunday, April 11, 2010
How to Become Wealthy - by Joshua Kennon
Nine Truths That Can Set You on the Path to Financial Freedom
#1: Change the Way You Think About Money
The general population has a love / hate relationship with wealth. They resent those who have it, but spend their entire lives attempting to get it for themselves. The reason a vast majority of people never accumulate a substantial nest egg is because they don't understand the nature of money or how it works.
Cash, like a person, is a living thing. When you wake up in the morning and go to work, you are selling a product - yourself (or more specifically, your labor). When you realize that every morning your assets wake up and have the same potential to work as you do, you unlock a powerful key in your life. Each dollar you save is like an employee. Over the course of time, the goal is to make your employees work hard, and eventually, they will make enough money to hire more workers (cash). When you have become truly successful, you no longer have to sell your own labor, but can live off of the labor of your assets.
#2: Develop an Understanding of the Power of Small Amounts
The biggest mistake most people make is that they think they have to start with an entire Napoleon-like army. They suffer from the "not enough" mentality; namely that if they aren't making $1,000 or $5,000 investments at a time, they will never become rich. What these people don't realize is that entire armies are built one soldier at a time; so too is their financial arsenal.
A friend of mine once knew a woman who worked as a dishwasher and made her purses out of used liquid detergent bottles. This woman invested and saved everything she had despite it never being more than a few dollars at a time. Now, her portfolio is worth millions upon millions of dollars, all of which was built upon small investments. I am not suggesting you become this frugal, but the lesson is still a valuable one. Do not despise the day of small beginnings!
#3: With Each Dollar You Save, You Are Buying Yourself Freedom
When you put it in these terms, you see how spending $20 here and $40 there can make a huge difference in the long run. Since money has the ability to work in your place, the more of it you employ, the faster and larger it will grow. Along with more money comes more freedom - the freedom to stay home with your kids, the freedom to retire and travel around the world, or the freedom to quit your job. If you have any source of income, it is possible for you to start building wealth today. It may only be $5 or $10 at a time, but each of those investments is a stone in the foundation of your financial freedom.
#4: You Are Responsible for Where You Are in Your Life
Years ago, a friend told me she didn't want to invest in stocks because she "didn't want to wait ten years to be rich..." she would rather enjoy her money now. The folly with this school of thinking is that the odds are, you are going to be alive in ten years. The question is whether or not you will be better off when you arrive there. Where you are right now is the sum total of the decisions you have made in the past. Why not set the stage for your life in the future right now?
#5: Instead of Buying the Product... Buy the Stock!
Someone once asked me why they weren't wealthy. They always felt like they were putting money aside, yet never seemed to get any further ahead. The answer is simple. I told them to stop buying the products companies sell and start buying the company itself! A survey of America's affluent (those who make over $225,000 a year or own $3,000,000 in assets) revealed that 27-30% of all the income the wealthy earned went into investments and savings. That isn't a result of being rich, that is why they are rich. When the pain of getting out of the bondage of financial slavery is greater than the pain of changing your spending habits, you will become rich. Either change, or be content to live as you are.
#6: Study and Admire Success and Those Who Have Achieved It... Then Emulate It
A very wise investor once said to pick the traits you admire and dislike the most about your heroes, then do everything in your power to develop the traits you like and reject the ones you don't. Mold yourself into who you want to become. You'll find that by investing in yourself first, money will begin to flow into your life. Success and wealth beget success and wealth. You have to purchase your way into that cycle, and you do so by building your army one soldier at a time and putting your money to work for you.
#7: Realize that More Money is Not the Answer
More money is not going to solve your problem. Money is a magnifying glass; it will accelerate and bring to light your true habits. If you are not capable of handling a job paying $18,000 a year, the worst possible thing that could happen to you is for you to earn six figures. It would destroy you. I have met too many people earning $100,000 a year who are living from paycheck to paycheck and don't understand why it is happening. The problem isn't the size of their checkbook, it is the way in which they were taught to use money.
#8: Unless Your Parents Were Wealthy, Don't Do What They Did
The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result. If your parents were not living the life you want to live then don't do what they did! You must break away from the mentality of past generations if you want to have a different lifestyle than they had.
To achieve the financial freedom and success that your family may or may not have had, you have to do two things. First, make a firm commitment to get out of debt. To find out which debts should be paid off before you invest and those that are acceptable, read Pay Off Your Debt or Invest?. Second, make saving and investing the highest financial priority in your life; one technique is to pay yourself first.
Purchasing equity is vital to your financial success as an individual whether you are in need of cash income or desire long-term appreciation in stock value. Nowhere else can your money do as much for you as when you use it to invest in a business that has wonderful long-term prospects.
#9: Don't Worry
The miracle of life is that it doesn't matter so much where you are, it matters where you are going. Once you have made the choice to take control back of your life by building up your net worth, don't give a second thought to the "what ifs". Every moment that goes by, you are growing closer and closer to your ultimate goal - control and freedom.
Every dollar that passes through your hands is a seed to your financial future. Rest assured, if you are diligent and responsible, financial prosperity is an inevitability. The day will come when you make your last payment on your car, your house, or whatever else it is you owe. Until then, enjoy the process.
Copyright © 2001 Joshua Kennon
(from http://beginnersinvest.about.com/cs/personalfinance1/a/blwealthy.htm )
Saturday, April 3, 2010
Quotes: "I don't throw darts at a board. I bet on sure things"
Sun Tzu says, "Every battle is won before it's ever fought.”
"You make money when you buy, NOT when you sell."
Think about it!.
Thursday, April 1, 2010
Quotes: "A man should practice what he preaches, but a man should also preach what he practices."
He also says, "If you think in terms of a year, plant a seed; if in terms of ten years, plant trees; if in terms of 100 years, teach the people. "
More quotes from Confucious: http://www.1000ventures.com/business_guide/crosscuttings/cultures_confucius.html
Saturday, March 6, 2010
Some Questions (Q) and Answers (A) about investing
A: I don't use that, because i don't forecast/ project. I don't see any difference in forecast vs speculate, which to me, both are gambling. Ask any person who does business/ in the sales line, and ask them to project their income growth "accurately" (some so-called analyst even project to 2 decimal point), which i find it amusing.
Q: What is the Risk free Rate for Malaysian stocks
A: There is no such thing as "risk-free rate for stocks". All stocks have Risk (and depending your definition of "risk", all financial instruments have risk, including FD which have one of the highest risk of inflation "depreciating" your money).
Academicians and Statisticians defines risk as "volatility (or fluctuation) of its price around their return". Based on such definition, Risk Free Rate in Malaysia (if you're asking that) is the FD rate. Depending on your definition again, it could be 1 month FD, 1 year FD, or even the FD rate that you're getting.
Q: Identify good companies
A: A good company is one which consistently generates high Return on Equity on its normalised earnings. A good company might not mean a good investment (if you're paying a high price for it), though it's a good place to start.
Wednesday, January 27, 2010
Integrity & Investment Performance
Quote by Charlie Munger
From the article of Stableboy Selections, i borrow his definition of Investing. "Investing is the process of putting money away now to be sure of getting more money back in the future."
If you agree with this definition, then you'll realize most people Speculate rather than Invest. No wonder they have poor long term results. (Do you know any gamblers who have good long term results? However, I know a lot of Casinos that earned a good long term results)
Read his article here: http://stableboyselections.com/2008/05/11/integrity-investment-performance/
Tuesday, January 26, 2010
Warren Buffett on long term value investing
http://www.tomspencer.com.au/2008/04/06/warren-buffett-on-long-term-value-investing/
A must read for Buffett wannabe!



After digging about Avenue Hotel Property Scheme, i thought it might be a good thing to share here.
Info about Avenue Hotel Property Scheme (PDF).
Company's website: Avenue Properties Bhd.
My research:
1) From the prospectus (http://avenuepropertiesberhad.com/pdf/avenueproperties_prospectus.pdf), look at page 40. The company’s RM 5 Million paid up capital is NOT funded by cash, but by Director’s words that he owes the company RM 5 Million. Then, at page 40, it says that amount is unsecured, interest free and without fixed repayment terms. In other words, this is a RM 2 company in disguise. To stretch that matter further, i can even create a company which is owned by me and my wife, paid up capital of say…. RM 100 Billion, with the only asset of the company is that i owed the company RM 100 Billion.
How much is a “Guarantee” worth if that person DON'T have any assets and NO income? Do you think the bank would lend such person Millions (or for that matter, even thousands) ? Why would we treat this company differently?
2) The Trustee they use (My Premier Trustee) is not registered (http://www.sc.com.my/eng/html/resources/stats/RegisteredTrustees.pdf). Why don’t they use registered trustee ? I asked the same question to a so called “Property investment company”, and that promoter's answer was, “Tell you what, you form one with the same terms using registered Trustee, and i’ll invest with you.”.
Today, that company is no longer around (after separating quite a number of ignorant and possibly greedy people from their money). hhmm……
3) Look at My Premier’s Trustee’s company profile ( http://www.mpt.com.my/Company%20Profile%202011.pdf) . Then, take a look at the companies they worked with. Notice none are companies u heard of. Next, google those companies. And……
3a) AZZ Marketing. Some headlines when u search in google (in 1st page) are,
– “AZZ Marketing Tidak Bayar Hasil Pemilik”
– “Azz Marketing menipu jutaan ringgit duit rakyat”
– “AZZ Marketing Berhad Pelaburan Ikan Keli Penipu!”
- Facebook Group – bongkar AZZ Marketing. (http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=155223407845386).
The funny thing is, My Premier Trustee on their website says that they’re not trustee for AZZ Marketing Enterprise, but only for AZZ Marketing Bhd. But when you go to main page of AZZ Marketing Bhd (http://www.azz4u.com/) , and you clicked on the bottom link http://www.kppazzmarketing.blogspot.com/ , that page wrote in their title , “KESATUAN PEMILIK PAKEJ AZZ MARKETING ENTERPRISE “. I might not be smart, but definitely i’m Not dumb to know that AZZ Marketing Bhd is related to AZZ Marketing Enterprise, and My Premier Trustee is related to both of these companies one way or another.
3b) Arowana Ventures Sdn. Bhd. – Google it, and the scam has been a few years ago. I remembered surfing their website, and it’s closed. Now, it’s reopened again, promising a certain guaranteed return.
– Read the lowyat’s forum (http://forum.lowyat.net/topic/2100249/all). I’m surprised they Recycle the same scam again.
– Posted in June 2009 in investlah.com (http://www.investlah.com/forum/index.php?topic=3234.0). Search for “Arowana”.
Same guarantees with all companies in MPT’s portfolio, different product. I wonder does “Ikan Keli” is the malay word for Arowana Fish. If that is so, that scammer really good in Recycling.
3c) Search ” Prestige Diary Farm Berhad” on google, and on the main page, you’ll get:
- [SCAM] Prestige Dairy Farm (M) Sdn Bhd (832757-A) [Archive …” (http://www.carigold.com/portal/forums/archive/index.php?t-57912.html)
- “Prestige Dairy Farm memang scam – Topix” (http://www.topix.com/forum/world/brunei/TCM4J1NON9DPOE8UH/p34)
- “Scam or Not? Prestige Dairy Farm” (forum.lowyat.net/topic/834067/+60)
– “Skim cepat kaya versi baru : Labur dalam syarikat penternakan” (http://www.saifulsham.com/2008/skim-cepat-kaya-versi-baru-labur-dalam-syarikat-penternakan/)
Also, forumers commented that the person behind “Prestige Diary Farm” and “Arowana Ventures” is the same person.
3d) Look at ICT Venture – the structure looks about the same as all the rest too.
Now, what does all these companies have in common:
1) They give Guaranteed Return.
2) The Return is way higher than FD (otherwise, how to lure the greedy + igporant people from “safe” bank?).
3) THey give referral fee for promoting it, or it’s promoted by 3rd party marketeer.
4) THEY USES MY PREMIER TRUSTEE.
5) And lastly, … after a few years, the company is gone, like David Copperfied’s magic trick.
Now, let’s assume we’re not sure “Avenue Hotel Property Scheme” is a scam or not. If that is so, then that means we’re not sure we might get back our Capital or not. Now, at 7% return, it’ll take 15 years for us to get back all our capital. Forget about Opportunity Cost lost during this 15 years. If that is not long, well, i don’t know what is.
For the benefit of people who have already invested, i suggest you try to get back your refund. If can’t get back refund, then let’s pray that this is NOT a scam. After all, if it talks like one, acts like one, breath like one, smells like one, …… Maybe it might Not be one.
Nevertheless, here’s more facts :
First, let’s look at REIT’s Trustees. I’ve found there are 14 REITs in Malaysia, and below are the REITs and the Trustee they used. Note that AR stands for Annual Report. All AR can be obtained (and verified) from http://www.bursamalaysia.com/ .
1. AMANAH HARTA TANAH PNB – Amanah Raya Berhad (page 2 of 2010′s AR)
2. AMANAHRAYA REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUST – CIMB Trustee Berhad (page 4 of 2010′s AR)
3. AMFIRST REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUST – Mayban Trustees Berhad (page 5 of 2011′s AR)
4. ATRIUM REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUST – BHLB Trustee Berhad (page 15 of 2010′s AR)
5. AXIS REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUST – OSK Trustees Berhad ( page 3 of 2010′s AR)
6. AL-HADHARAH BOUSTEAD REIT – CIMB Trustee Berhad (page 28 of 2010′s AR)
7. CAPITAMALLS MALAYSIA TRUST – AmTrustee Berhad (page 20 of 2010′s AR)
8. HEKTAR REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUST – AmTrustee Berhad (page 32 of 2010′s AR)
9. AL-’AQAR KPJ REIT – Amanah Raya Berhad ( page 5 of 2010′s AR)
10. QUILL CAPITA TRUST – Mayban Trustees Berhad ( page 2 of 2010′s AR)
11. STARHILL REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUST – Mayban Trustees Berhad (page 14 of 2011′s AR)
12. SUNWAY REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUST – OSK Trustees Berhad (page 7 of 2011′s AR)
13. TOWER REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUST – Am Trustee Bhd (page 3 of 2010′s AR)
14. UOA REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUST – OSK Trustees Berhad ( page 5 of 2010′s AR)
How many of the 14 REIT uses Trustee that is listed in SC’s website? ALL !!!Or, let me rephrase the question differently. How many of the 14 REIT uses non-registered Trustee ? NONE !.
Just in case someone might say that this interest scheme by SSM is different from REIT or Unit Trust (since both REIT and Unit Trust uses registered Trustee which can be found in SC’s website), i’ve dug further to the SSM’s interest scheme companies.
There are currently 3 types of interest scheme in SSM, Sharefarming Scheme , Equipment Sharing and this Property Scheme. For convinience, let me list all the companies below, and the trustee they used.
- AZZ MARKETING BERHAD – MY PREMIER TRUSTEE
- GOLDEN PALM GROWERS BERHAD – AmTrustee Berhad – ( http://goldenpalm.com.my/auditors.html )
- PLENTIFUL GOLD-CLASS BERHAD – BHLB Trustee Berhad ( http://www.chgs.com.my/trustee.asp )
- AROWANA VENTURE BERHAD – MY PREMIER TRUSTEE
- SWIFTLET ECO PARK BERHAD – PB Trustee Berhad ( http://www.swiftletecopark.com.my/scheme_why_esris_5key.htm
- EAST WEST ONE CONSORTIUM BERHAD – Equity Trust (Malaysia) Bhd – ( page 10 of the company’s eprospectus here: http://www.eastwestone.com/downloads_eprospectus.html )
- ICT ZONE VENTURES BERHAD – MY PREMIER TRUSTEE
- AVENUE PROPERTIES BERHAD – MY PREMIER TRUSTEE
All companies uses Trustee that can be found in SC’s website (which are registered), except for 4 companies below:
1) AZZ MARKETING BERHAD
2) AROWANA VENTURE BERHAD
3) ICT ZONE VENTURES BERHAD, and
4) AVENUE PROPERTIES BERHAD
The 4 companies uses the SAME Trustee, which is My Premier Trustee, which is NOT a Registered trustee in SC’s website. Isn’t that alarming?
Before looking for Guaranteed return, why not ask a more fundamental question? Where does the money comes from to pay the Guaranteed return since the business’s Revenue, Cost and thus Profit (be it Computer Rental or Arowana or Property) is NOT Guaranteed?
As for CT Choo’s website, i googled further, and i found that this website of his ( https://sites.google.com/site/ctchoocap/home?pli=1 ) states that they’re working closely with My Premier Trustee.
And this website of My Premier Trustee ( http://mypremiertrustee.blogspot.com/ ) have only 3 post, created only in August 2010, but have one post which is sourced from CT Choo.
I’ll let you guys form your own conclusion.
p/s: For the promoters of this scheme, please tell these companies to change trustee to registered trustee. Or, get My Premier Trustee registered with SC. However, if you still believe that it’s a good scheme, i suggest you to invite your wife, parents, relatives and all close friends to invest besides you investing at least 10% of your Net Worth there yourself.
p/p/s: And if you own a house, you can actually get FREE money. How? Refinance your house to AIA or ING and get a fixed rate housing loan (say 30 years). Then take this lump sum and put (i avoid using the word “invest” since it doesn’t qualify as one as per Benjamin Graham’s definition) in this “Scheme”. Free money every year.
HOWEVER, I STRONGLY ADVICE AGAINST THIS ! Being Greedy combine with Ignorant is bad enough. And if you add in Leverage to Greed and Ignorance , disaster awaits superbly soon!